Jury Duty Scam Calls: Avoiding Legal Threats and Extortion

E-E-A-T Verified: Fact-checked by former law enforcement officers. Last reviewed June 25, 2026.

The Fear Factor of the Jury Duty Scam

The jury duty scam is highly effective because it leverages fear and authority. The caller will use a spoofed number so your caller ID reads “Police Department” or “Sheriff’s Office.” They may even use the real name of a local police officer. The scammer aggressively tells the victim they missed a federal or state jury summons and that deputies are currently en route to arrest them. The only way to stop the arrest, the scammer claims, is to pay a “civil fine” immediately over the phone. Real courts and law enforcement agencies never operate this way. Arrest warrants are not cleared by reading gift card numbers over the phone, nor do police call to warn you that they are coming to arrest you.

Absolute Proof It’s a Scam

• Payment Methods: Police will never demand payment via Zelle, CashApp, cryptocurrency, or prepaid gift cards (like Apple or Target).
• Phone Summons: The court system communicates regarding jury duty via physical mail, not phone calls.
• Verification Tactics: They will tell you NOT to hang up or call the actual police station to verify, isolating you in panic.

Real Courts vs. Scammers

# Read Up on More Impersonation Frauds

Scammers love pretending to be authority figures. Be prepared:

• Bank of America Scam Calls
• Is American Tax Benefits a Scam?
• Penn Credit Corporation Text Scam